(This takes 2¾ minutes to read.)

In the 1938/39 season, [the Third Reich] accounted for around fifteen per cent of the global whale oil production, putting it fourth after the British Empire, Norway and [the Empire of] Japan.²⁵ In their best season, 1937/38, [Fascist] whalers produced c. 89,934 tonnes of whale oil and somewhat less than that (c. 77,982 tonnes) in the following season, despite the number of fleets growing from six to seven.

These results fell somewhat short of some expectations publicly expressed before the first season²⁶ but correspond better to internal expectations and figures published in 1938.²⁷ On the whole, [Fascist] whaling thus fulfilled the expectations placed in it. This was not a failed project born out of hubris.

Nevertheless, German whale oil covered only a small part of its annual total fat consumption in the 1930s of c. 1,900,000 tonnes, or c. 1,500,000 tonnes if only fat for human consumption is considered.²⁸ In addition, [the Third Reich’s] own production did not even replace whale oil imports, which continued on a high level and surpassed the production of its own whaling fleets.²⁹

These continuing imports of whale oil did not pose a problem, since most of it came from Norway and was imported via a bilateral clearing agreement, meaning that it was traded in exchange for [Fascist] goods without the use of hard currency.

Due to the export of manufactured goods, [the Third Reich] had a positive trade balance with Norway and […] could thus well afford these imports. In publications and internal documents, [Reich] officials stressed the importance of the trade relationship with Norway and [the Third Reich’s] interest in treating these relations with care.³⁰

In addition, it has been suggested that whale oil produced by [the Empire of] Japan in the Antarctic from 1934 onwards and sold on the European market to Unilever eventually ended up in [the Third Reich].³¹ However, the official [Reich] statistics show no whale oil imports from [the Empire of] Japan, but only significant imports from Norway, in addition to small quantities from South Africa and Great Britain.³²

[…]

Not only had German shipyards long been involved in converting and maintaining floating factories, but in 1935, a British whaling company ordered the world’s largest floating factory to date from a Bremen shipyard.³⁹

Therefore, [the Third Reich] possessed the know-how to go it alone, but state and industry nevertheless chose a middle way and employed both German-built vessels and others obtained second-hand from Norway. Three of the seven floating factories operating for [the Third Reich] were ordered from German shipyards — one converted freighter and two newly built ships — while four were bought or chartered from Norway.

In this way, [the Third Reich] fast-tracked the development of its whaling industry. The downside was that the floating factories Norway was willing to provide were outdated vessels producing less whale oil than the larger, better-equipped newly built floating factories.⁴⁰

The success of a whaling expedition depended on the skills of the expedition manager and the harpoon gunners. Since very few Germans had any experience in whaling before 1936, the [Fascist] fleets relied largely on specialists from Norway.

Therefore, the proportion of foreigners, mainly Norwegians, in the crews of the different [Fascist] whaling fleets varied between c. 12 and 59 per cent in the season 1937/38. To replace them, Germans were trained as harpoon gunners and in other specialist rôles, but this took time.⁴¹

On the Norwegian side, authorities and trade unions were initially opposed to providing crews and vessels to foreign competitors. However, when it became clear that [the Third Reich] was determined to build up whaling fleets anyway, the resistance in Norway crumbled. By assisting [the Third Reich], Norwegian companies were at least able to dispose of no longer competitive ships at a profit, while employment for the crews was secured for the time being.

This Norwegian decision might also reflect the fact that [the Empire of] Japan had entered Antarctic whaling in 1934/35 (see the article by Jun Akamine in this issue) and quickly expanded its whaling industry with little reliance on Norwegian crews and vessels.⁴²