• couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    11
    ·
    2 days ago

    Would you say the genocide against ISIS was justified?

    (Not a trick question or something, just that I would argue that, sometimes, it’s not so easy)

    • CanIFishHere@lemmy.caBanned from community
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      1 day ago

      That statement doesn’t make sense ISIS is not a people, it’s a terrorist organization. Not a trick question, but definitely one that doesn’t make sense.

    • mechoman444@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      9
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      2 days ago

      ISIS is objectively a terrorist organization composed of radicalized, violent individuals pursuing a very specific political and ideological agenda. They are not an indigenous population, an ethnic group, or a civilian population defined by geography. They are an organized terrorist organization. There is a fundamental difference, and pretending otherwise demonstrates a remarkable inability to distinguish between categories of people and political movements.

      And before you attempt to conflate this with religion, there is no such thing as a Muslim terrorist as a distinct category of terrorism. There are terrorists. Their religious affiliation does not somehow redefine the nature of their crimes or grant them immunity from accountability.

      ISIS would happily commit genocide against entire populations if those populations failed to conform to its ideology. They have demonstrated precisely that willingness. So spare me the manufactured moral equivalence. I have no obligation to extend sympathy to an organization whose explicit ambitions include the systematic extermination of people it considers undesirable.

      And as for Gaza, your apparent difficulty understanding the scale of the devastation is almost comical. Open Google Earth. Look at the satellite imagery. Look at what remains of entire neighborhoods. This is not some obscure, difficult-to-access piece of information requiring specialized research or an advanced degree in geopolitical analysis. It is quite literally one of the easiest things you could do to educate yourself.

      The fact that I have to explain the distinction between a terrorist organization and a civilian population while simultaneously directing you to satellite imagery to establish the physical reality of Gaza is genuinely embarrassing. At some point, intellectual dishonesty stops being an excuse for ignorance and becomes a conscious choice.

      • Malyca@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        1 day ago

        Apple has replaced the map images with previous ones, so it looks like the buildings are still there. I bet Google does too. Disgusting pieces of shit.

        • mechoman444@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          1 day ago

          Ya… It looks like Google has practically redacted or replaced large swaths of the destruction with older satellite imagery. You can still see some destruction but not remotely as much.

          Fucking sick.

      • KatakiY@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        2 days ago

        I get your frustration and you’re probably right about the person you are responding to.

        But I feel like it’s easy to forget thatnthere are teenagers and young adults who simply do not have the information to rationally connect the dots or just haven’t been involved in international politics.

        In a vacuum it’s a completely understandable question to ask. In context it’s obviously leading and the comparison is gross…but sometimes people say ignorant shit while they are learning.

        I’m probably being too generous but I always think about some of the questions my kid asks when trying to figure out the world.

      • couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        3
        ·
        2 days ago

        objectively

        Well that’s the point I’m making, of course.

        For you ISIS are so bad that they deserved to be genocided. (You’re incorrect about the ethnic and local connection btw, but that isn’t really the point here). Men, women and children under the axe until they were defeated.

        For a lot of Israelis, Hamas are such bad people that they deserve to be genocided. In the Balkans, a lot of people thought that their neighbours were such bad people that they had no right to the land and had to be genocided.

        With one question you’ve gone from “Hamas is a terrorist organisation but nonetheless, genocide is never justified” to “ISIS is a terrorist organisation so the genocide was totally justified”

        • mechoman444@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          1 day ago

          You clearly don’t understand what genocide means, and frankly, I’m not interested in debating the definition with you.

          There is absolutely no credible argument, evidence, or rhetorical gymnastics that can establish that Israel is not committing genocide against the ethnic population of Gaza. It is. That is an established reality, not a matter of opinion.

          More importantly, you cannot commit genocide against ISIS in the same sense that you cannot commit genocide against members of the YMCA. ISIS is an organization, not an ethnic population. Eliminating an organization, regardless of how reprehensible its members may be, is not inherently genocide.

          Furthermore, I have never advocated for eliminating ISIS. I have never advocated for killing a single person, for any reason. I oppose the death penalty. I don’t believe anyone should be put to death. So why are you inventing positions for me? You are arguing against a position I have never held, apparently because you cannot address what I actually said.

          And let’s be perfectly clear about something: if your position is that Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza, you are a genocide denier. You are lying about an atrocity that has been extensively documented. I don’t believe this is a matter of innocent disagreement or a difference in interpretation. At some point, dismissing the evidence and insisting that an established atrocity isn’t happening becomes deliberate dishonesty. You are a liar, and I have absolutely no interest in pretending otherwise or extending the courtesy of civilized debate to someone who refuses to engage with reality.

          • couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zip
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            arrow-down
            1
            ·
            1 day ago

            I have never advocated for eliminating ISIS

            When you say “ISIS so bad. I have no obligation to extend sympathy” wrt a genocide being put on them, what else does it mean than that you at least not oppose their elimination?

            ISIS is an organisation, not an ethnic population

            ISIS was like 90+% indiginous people, even more when they started as a resistance group in Iraq. They were part of the population that wanted to see ‘their’ territory cleaned and brought under their control.

            if your position is that Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza

            What makes you think that?

            • mechoman444@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              arrow-down
              1
              ·
              1 day ago

              If ISIS were to be dismantled, eliminated, defeated, or otherwise destroyed, I wouldn’t lose a moment of sleep over it. They’re a terrorist organization that has absolutely no qualms about murdering innocent people, publicly beheading captives, and committing atrocities to advance their political agenda.

              And I am not going to engage with you in a never-ending battle of definitions and semantics. You cannot commit genocide against an organization. Genocide is the attempted destruction of a protected human population based on its national, ethnic, racial, or religious identity. ISIS is an organization, not a protected population.

              The fact that ISIS has historically been composed largely of indigenous people from the territories in which it operated doesn’t change that distinction. Eliminating ISIS as an organization is not the same thing as exterminating Iraqis, Syrians, Muslims, or any other population.

              And what makes me think you might have a problem with that distinction? Oh, I don’t know… Perhaps your apparent willingness to defend a violent terrorist organization that has demonstrated, time and time again, its willingness to murder, torture, and exterminate people who don’t subscribe to its ideology?

              • couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zip
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                17 hours ago

                The Islamic State was just that: a caliphate vying to be a state for salafist sunnis. With their own governance, education, currency etc. . You might not like it. I might not like it. But that doesn’t mean they did not have a society built on their religious and cultural identity. It’s just that you decide that this identity is so utterly shit that you don’t want to consider it to be something worthy to be protected from genocide.

                your apparent willingness to defend a violent terrorist organization

                What makes you think that?

                • mechoman444@lemmy.world
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  16 hours ago

                  ISIS is an organization in the same sense that Microsoft is an organization or the Republican Party is an organization. There aren’t even that many members, probably somewhere around 18,000 worldwide, spread across various factions and geographical regions. You cannot commit genocide against an organization as the term is currently defined. ISIS does not constitute a society, any more than Microsoft or the Republican Party constitutes a society.

                  You are being disingenuous and arguing in bad faith. You have misrepresented my position through an enormous straw man. And don’t ask me what your straw man is. You clearly don’t understand what a straw man argument is, and I’m not going to explain it to you.

                  You keep asking what makes me think you’re denying genocide and supporting ISIS. It’s the language you’re using in your responses. Your own words are what lead me to that conclusion. Stop asking me to explain your own position to you. You know what you’re saying, and you know the implications of your own arguments.

                  • couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zip
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    arrow-down
                    1
                    ·
                    15 hours ago

                    At its high point, there were around 10.000.000 people living in the ISIS.

                    To defeat them, a genocide was not just put on those with AK’s - it was put on all 10 million of them. Fighters, mothers and babies.

                    Trying to justify the genocide with “I just mean just the terrorists bro!” is exactly what I’m trying to open your eyes to.

                    It’s the language