Bourgeois democracy rests entirely on the fact that capitalists own the economy and therefore control the state. That’s why every reformist has failed, period. Whenever there is a risk that capitalism may be threatened via legal means, the capitalist class rips off the veneer of democracy and ruled in a gangster fashion. This is the basis of fascism.
I understand that you aren’t a Marxist, and I understand the desire to avoid revolution. However, it seems you do not have an answer on how you will avoid American Pinochet in the event you ever gain electotal representation, nor a developed analysis of the capitalist state that points to being able to swap it out piece by piece into socialism.
We can yap about the benefits of the USSR or its shortcomings all we like, but reformism is a non-starter.
Regarding the 1930s soviet famine, even serious liberal scholars believe it to have been a combination of adverse weather conditions and mismanagement. For instance, Mark Tauger wrote:
[data] indicate that the famine was real, the result of a failure of economic policy, of the ‘revolution from above,’ rather than of a ‘successful’ nationality policy against Ukrainians or other ethnic groups.
Tauger believes it was a failure of economic policy, not an intentional attack on ethnic Ukrainians. The 1930s famine was a combination of drought, flooding, and mismanagement. Further, the Kulaks, wealthy bourgeois farmers, magnified matters by killing their own crops in the midst of a famine rather than letting the Red Army collectivize them. The Politburo was also kept in the dark about how bad the famine was getting:
From: Archive of the President of the Russian Federation. Fond 3, Record Series 40, File 80, Page 58.
Excerpt from the protocol number of the meeting of the Political Bureau of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist party (Bolsheviks) “Regarding Measures to Prevent Failure to Sow in Ukraine, March 16th, 1932.
The Political Bureau believes that shortage of seed grain in Ukraine is many times worse than what was described in comrade Kosior’s telegram; therefore, the Political Bureau recommends the Central Committee of the Communist party of Ukraine to take all measures within its reach to prevent the threat of failing to sow [field crops] in Ukraine.
Signed: Secretary of the Central Committee – J. STALIN
Letter to Joseph Stalin from Stanislaw Kosior, 1st secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine regarding the course and the perspectives of the sowing campaign in Ukraine, April 26th, 1932.
There are also isolated cases of starvation, and even whole villages [starving]; however, this is only the result of bungling on the local level, deviations [from the party line], especially in regard of kolkhozes. All rumours about “famine” in Ukraine must be unconditionally rejected. The crucial help that was provided for Ukraine will give us the opportunity to eradicate all such outbreaks [of starvation].
Letter from Joseph Stalin to Stanislaw Kosior, 1st secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine, April 26th, 1932.
Comrade Kosior!
You must read attached summaries. Judging by this information, it looks like the Soviet authority has ceased to exist in some areas of the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic. Can this be true? Is the situation in villages in Ukraine this bad? Where are the operatives of the OGPU [Joint Main Political Directorate], what are they doing?
Could you verify this information and inform the Central Committee of
the All-Union Communist party about taken measures.
Sincerely, J. Stalin
Evidence doesn’t point to deliberately killing some of the Soviet Union’s most loyal citizens in the breadbasket of the entire USSR, when they desperately needed to advance agricultural production (and did). Once it became clear that famine was occurring, grain was redirected to the region to mitigate the effects as best as possible, which took time to finally eliminate.
I don’t agree that reform is a non-starter.
Reform has failed so far, but giving up is not what I consider to be a good solution.
I think that it is possible to modify a legal system to become inoculated against wealth
such that there can never be a capitalist class.
There’s a lot of work to be done, but it’s good work, and I think it’s worth it.
I’m saying that there’s no actual basis to anything you’ve said, just vibes. I admire the optimism, but I suggest you direct it in a more scientific manner. As it stands, you have absolutely no reason to believe you aren’t spinning your wheels, and when workers ask you why this time will be different, you’ll lack an answer.
That’s a reasonable fear, I suppose.
It may also be worth noting that socialism has never co-existed well with social liberties for a prolonged period of time (although most systems have not co-existed well with social liberties).
I think we stand a better chance of making a system that both gives people freedoms and provides for people if we do it through democratic means.
Whether it will be successful is yet to be known, but I’m going to keep fighting that fight.
I’m sorry, but I entirely disagree. Socialism has always co-existed with civil liberties for a prolonged period of time. You mentioned Stalin as eroding the basis of socialism, but have you actually looked into how life was like for the average worker in the 1930s?
The former USSR had a system of councils, from the local to the highest levels. Local councils elected delegates from among them to form higher councils, who in-turn elected delegates to higher councils. Each rung democratically selected among itself who can best represent them. In the west, we are used to ritualistically electing the head of state every few years, whereas in socialist countries democracy plays more of an active role in people’s day to day life.
In the Soviet Union, factories were run by a trio, called the “Triangle.” There was the manager of the factory, who typically worked their way up from the bottom. There was the party representative, who was there to bring a more all-sided viewpoint that local viewpoints may miss. Finally, there was the trade union representative, who was elected by the rest of the workers at the factory. The trade unions set wage agreements, controlled the wall-newspaper (a form of newsletter for the factory), and were in charge of making sure the needs and interests of the rank and file were met. Unpopular managers were thrown out by the trade unions.
This is just a microscopic slice of how the socialist system actually functioned. Education was free from cradle to grave, healthcare was free, rent was about 10% of incomes. It’s easy to imagine a vignette and believe it to be reality, but when you actually look at historical reality it paints an extremely different picture from what our guts tell us. Our gut feelings have been shaped by the Red Scare, whether we realize it or not.
I think we stand a better chance of making a system that both gives people freedoms and provides for people if we do it through democratic means.
And this is where I am asking the simple question: why? On what material basis? Why will this time be different? Revolution has already established democratic systems of socialism, and reformism has never done so. Why do you think your strategy will work?
Socialism has always co-existed with civil liberties for a prolonged period of time.
Were some civil liberties preserved? Absolutely!
Education, healthcare, and low rents were very real impacts of that socialist system.
The USSR did a great job in that regard.
But other civil liberties, like freedom of speech and freedom from surveillance, were heavily restricted, especially toward the end of the USSR.
Why will this time be different?
We could hold another revolution, but I could pose the same question:
why will it be different from all the revolutions that collapsed into authoritarianism?
Neither reform nor revolution has worked sustainably to build a system that survives long-term and respects rights while also protecting its people from ignorance, starvation, and lack of healthcare.
I think it’s worth it to keep trying instead of giving up.
Another revolution would cost more lives and fall into authoritarian hands the same way.
Who knows: maybe it wouldn’t.
But I prefer a democratic solution.
And I think a system founded on democracy has a better chance of maintaining democracy.
In part, this is because people are more likely to revolt against a system that was imposed upon them than a system they participated in from the beginning.
We don’t have to see eye to eye, but I hope you at least agree that my stance isn’t ludicrous.
I also want to clarify that I don’t think the USSR was entirely a failed government.
It did a lot of things well, but I think, especially as time progressed, it was limiting of individual freedoms that it should have respected and protected.
In the event that you take power, is your plan to leave capitalists with full freedom of speech, assembly, and with no surveillance? All states are class dictatorships. This means democracy for the ruling class, with the state oppressing that which works against the interests of the ruling class. This is why we cannot reform capitalism into socialism, but even magically assuming we get through that first hurdle and establish socialism electorally, what do you do about the capitalists?
To answer your question on “why would revolution be different,” my answer is that it would largely be the same, and that’s a great thing. Using the US as an example, if socialist revolution succeeded, we would already be far past much of what existing socialist states have had to struggle through, like advancing agriculture and industrialization. We would also have many of the same progressive aspects socialist states built with far fewer resources.
Socialist states are already democratic. The systems they put in place to fight against capital and protect the gains of socialism, such as people’s councils and democratic centralism, look utterly alien to us in the capitalist west, where we confuse the ritual of electing pre-selected heads of state every few years with democracy. I encourage you to not look at the hundreds of millions of workers that spent their lives building up socialism and fighting to protect it as foolish and ignorant, but instead to learn from them and carry their work forward.
Until you do so, I’m sorry, but I cannot see your stance as anything other than naive and unprincipled. I implore you to take a scientific approach, and be able to answer why reformism will work this time, otherwise everyone will eventually recognize the necessity of revolution as you fail to answer that important question.
In the event that you take power, is your plan to leave capitalists with full freedom of speech, assembly, and with no surveillance.
All people should have their individual rights and freedoms respected, including these people. There are other methods of preventing a ruling class, best used in conjunction:
A limit of the maximum personal wealth (in assets both liquid and unrealized) based on some multiple of the median, any excess of which is taxed.
A limit of income from any company based on some multiple of the income of that company’s least payed employee, any excess of which is redistributed to the employees of the company evenly.
Criminalization of lobbying the government with money or assets.
Criminalization of representative trading of stocks.
Strict enforcement of anti-emolument rules.
Strict enforcement of antitrust.
Separation of powers into many sections with short terms.
Ranked-choice voting to prevent a partisanship of few parties, which decays into a ‘lesser evil’ system like the unfortunate system in the US today.
As for surveillance, warrants should be required, and those being surveilled should always be made aware of their surveilled status.
Insofar as free speech is concerned, all people should be given total free speech with the exceptions of slander and calls to violence against minorities or any particular individual.
Socialist states are already democratic.
In some ways, yes.
In others, less so.
It really depends on the state and the window of time being analyzed.
Some states have been very authoritarian, while also being socialist,
at least during part of their lifespan.
I encourage you to not look at the hundreds of millions of workers that spent their lives building up socialism and fighting to protect it as foolish and ignorant
I don’t view them as foolish or ignorant.
They were intelligent people who had the same goal as I do.
I disagree with the methodology of some of them, but we are all working toward social equity.
I cannot see your stance as anything other than naive and unprincipled.
Part of my objection to revolt is the means.
The ends, in my view, do not justify the means
Nevertheless, your position is intelligent, and I respect it despite my disagreement.
I won’t bash you over the head with my stance, since I think it’s been discussed at length.
I think we must all practice intellectual humility;
we are likely both misguided in some way or another.
Still, I think disagreement is not always naïveté.
I have, as you, thought this through; we came to different conclusions, and that’s fine.
Discourse exists to confer ideas and reasoning, after all.
Whether we concur on methodology, our end goal is the same or similar, and that is more important than the method.
The measures you suggest do not limit the capitalist class, and allowing them to form coherent political blocs against the working class and overturn socialism is frankly a moralist stance that endangers the working class. The socialists that have succeeded in building socialism have built the strong protections they have out of necessity, not a simple desire to command. Throughout this comment, I’m still not understanding why you think this time will be different from every other time a well-meaning reformist has taken power and immediately been ousted by open gangsterism.
I don’t call you naive and unprincipled to be mean, I mean them quite literally, I don’t see any practical substance that tackles the problem of capitalist dictatorship nor addresses the history of the capitalist class violently resisting any and all progressive movements, reformist or revolutionary, every single time. I think you’re coasting off of hope, not science.
I love this response. This is precisely why- despite being an ‘idealist’ who is icked out by vanguard vibes- I support the PSL.
But I suppose it makes sense that an insurrectionary anarchist is more likely to get along with revolutionary socialists than a reformist socialist is.
Bourgeois democracy rests entirely on the fact that capitalists own the economy and therefore control the state. That’s why every reformist has failed, period. Whenever there is a risk that capitalism may be threatened via legal means, the capitalist class rips off the veneer of democracy and ruled in a gangster fashion. This is the basis of fascism.
I understand that you aren’t a Marxist, and I understand the desire to avoid revolution. However, it seems you do not have an answer on how you will avoid American Pinochet in the event you ever gain electotal representation, nor a developed analysis of the capitalist state that points to being able to swap it out piece by piece into socialism.
We can yap about the benefits of the USSR or its shortcomings all we like, but reformism is a non-starter.
Regarding the 1930s soviet famine, even serious liberal scholars believe it to have been a combination of adverse weather conditions and mismanagement. For instance, Mark Tauger wrote:
Tauger believes it was a failure of economic policy, not an intentional attack on ethnic Ukrainians. The 1930s famine was a combination of drought, flooding, and mismanagement. Further, the Kulaks, wealthy bourgeois farmers, magnified matters by killing their own crops in the midst of a famine rather than letting the Red Army collectivize them. The Politburo was also kept in the dark about how bad the famine was getting:
From: Archive of the President of the Russian Federation. Fond 3, Record Series 40, File 80, Page 58.
Excerpt from the protocol number of the meeting of the Political Bureau of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist party (Bolsheviks) “Regarding Measures to Prevent Failure to Sow in Ukraine, March 16th, 1932.
Letter to Joseph Stalin from Stanislaw Kosior, 1st secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine regarding the course and the perspectives of the sowing campaign in Ukraine, April 26th, 1932.
Letter from Joseph Stalin to Stanislaw Kosior, 1st secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine, April 26th, 1932.
Evidence doesn’t point to deliberately killing some of the Soviet Union’s most loyal citizens in the breadbasket of the entire USSR, when they desperately needed to advance agricultural production (and did). Once it became clear that famine was occurring, grain was redirected to the region to mitigate the effects as best as possible, which took time to finally eliminate.
I don’t agree that reform is a non-starter. Reform has failed so far, but giving up is not what I consider to be a good solution. I think that it is possible to modify a legal system to become inoculated against wealth such that there can never be a capitalist class.
There’s a lot of work to be done, but it’s good work, and I think it’s worth it.
I’m saying that there’s no actual basis to anything you’ve said, just vibes. I admire the optimism, but I suggest you direct it in a more scientific manner. As it stands, you have absolutely no reason to believe you aren’t spinning your wheels, and when workers ask you why this time will be different, you’ll lack an answer.
That’s a reasonable fear, I suppose. It may also be worth noting that socialism has never co-existed well with social liberties for a prolonged period of time (although most systems have not co-existed well with social liberties). I think we stand a better chance of making a system that both gives people freedoms and provides for people if we do it through democratic means. Whether it will be successful is yet to be known, but I’m going to keep fighting that fight.
I’m sorry, but I entirely disagree. Socialism has always co-existed with civil liberties for a prolonged period of time. You mentioned Stalin as eroding the basis of socialism, but have you actually looked into how life was like for the average worker in the 1930s?
The former USSR had a system of councils, from the local to the highest levels. Local councils elected delegates from among them to form higher councils, who in-turn elected delegates to higher councils. Each rung democratically selected among itself who can best represent them. In the west, we are used to ritualistically electing the head of state every few years, whereas in socialist countries democracy plays more of an active role in people’s day to day life.
In the Soviet Union, factories were run by a trio, called the “Triangle.” There was the manager of the factory, who typically worked their way up from the bottom. There was the party representative, who was there to bring a more all-sided viewpoint that local viewpoints may miss. Finally, there was the trade union representative, who was elected by the rest of the workers at the factory. The trade unions set wage agreements, controlled the wall-newspaper (a form of newsletter for the factory), and were in charge of making sure the needs and interests of the rank and file were met. Unpopular managers were thrown out by the trade unions.
This is just a microscopic slice of how the socialist system actually functioned. Education was free from cradle to grave, healthcare was free, rent was about 10% of incomes. It’s easy to imagine a vignette and believe it to be reality, but when you actually look at historical reality it paints an extremely different picture from what our guts tell us. Our gut feelings have been shaped by the Red Scare, whether we realize it or not.
And this is where I am asking the simple question: why? On what material basis? Why will this time be different? Revolution has already established democratic systems of socialism, and reformism has never done so. Why do you think your strategy will work?
Were some civil liberties preserved? Absolutely! Education, healthcare, and low rents were very real impacts of that socialist system. The USSR did a great job in that regard.
But other civil liberties, like freedom of speech and freedom from surveillance, were heavily restricted, especially toward the end of the USSR.
We could hold another revolution, but I could pose the same question: why will it be different from all the revolutions that collapsed into authoritarianism? Neither reform nor revolution has worked sustainably to build a system that survives long-term and respects rights while also protecting its people from ignorance, starvation, and lack of healthcare.
I think it’s worth it to keep trying instead of giving up. Another revolution would cost more lives and fall into authoritarian hands the same way. Who knows: maybe it wouldn’t. But I prefer a democratic solution. And I think a system founded on democracy has a better chance of maintaining democracy. In part, this is because people are more likely to revolt against a system that was imposed upon them than a system they participated in from the beginning.
We don’t have to see eye to eye, but I hope you at least agree that my stance isn’t ludicrous. I also want to clarify that I don’t think the USSR was entirely a failed government. It did a lot of things well, but I think, especially as time progressed, it was limiting of individual freedoms that it should have respected and protected.
In the event that you take power, is your plan to leave capitalists with full freedom of speech, assembly, and with no surveillance? All states are class dictatorships. This means democracy for the ruling class, with the state oppressing that which works against the interests of the ruling class. This is why we cannot reform capitalism into socialism, but even magically assuming we get through that first hurdle and establish socialism electorally, what do you do about the capitalists?
To answer your question on “why would revolution be different,” my answer is that it would largely be the same, and that’s a great thing. Using the US as an example, if socialist revolution succeeded, we would already be far past much of what existing socialist states have had to struggle through, like advancing agriculture and industrialization. We would also have many of the same progressive aspects socialist states built with far fewer resources.
Socialist states are already democratic. The systems they put in place to fight against capital and protect the gains of socialism, such as people’s councils and democratic centralism, look utterly alien to us in the capitalist west, where we confuse the ritual of electing pre-selected heads of state every few years with democracy. I encourage you to not look at the hundreds of millions of workers that spent their lives building up socialism and fighting to protect it as foolish and ignorant, but instead to learn from them and carry their work forward.
Until you do so, I’m sorry, but I cannot see your stance as anything other than naive and unprincipled. I implore you to take a scientific approach, and be able to answer why reformism will work this time, otherwise everyone will eventually recognize the necessity of revolution as you fail to answer that important question.
All people should have their individual rights and freedoms respected, including these people. There are other methods of preventing a ruling class, best used in conjunction:
As for surveillance, warrants should be required, and those being surveilled should always be made aware of their surveilled status.
Insofar as free speech is concerned, all people should be given total free speech with the exceptions of slander and calls to violence against minorities or any particular individual.
In some ways, yes. In others, less so. It really depends on the state and the window of time being analyzed. Some states have been very authoritarian, while also being socialist, at least during part of their lifespan.
I don’t view them as foolish or ignorant. They were intelligent people who had the same goal as I do. I disagree with the methodology of some of them, but we are all working toward social equity.
Part of my objection to revolt is the means. The ends, in my view, do not justify the means Nevertheless, your position is intelligent, and I respect it despite my disagreement. I won’t bash you over the head with my stance, since I think it’s been discussed at length.
I think we must all practice intellectual humility; we are likely both misguided in some way or another.
Still, I think disagreement is not always naïveté. I have, as you, thought this through; we came to different conclusions, and that’s fine. Discourse exists to confer ideas and reasoning, after all. Whether we concur on methodology, our end goal is the same or similar, and that is more important than the method.
The measures you suggest do not limit the capitalist class, and allowing them to form coherent political blocs against the working class and overturn socialism is frankly a moralist stance that endangers the working class. The socialists that have succeeded in building socialism have built the strong protections they have out of necessity, not a simple desire to command. Throughout this comment, I’m still not understanding why you think this time will be different from every other time a well-meaning reformist has taken power and immediately been ousted by open gangsterism.
I don’t call you naive and unprincipled to be mean, I mean them quite literally, I don’t see any practical substance that tackles the problem of capitalist dictatorship nor addresses the history of the capitalist class violently resisting any and all progressive movements, reformist or revolutionary, every single time. I think you’re coasting off of hope, not science.
I love this response. This is precisely why- despite being an ‘idealist’ who is icked out by vanguard vibes- I support the PSL.
But I suppose it makes sense that an insurrectionary anarchist is more likely to get along with revolutionary socialists than a reformist socialist is.
Yep, anarchists and Marxists can usually at least rally behind the need to fight the system itself!