• 0 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: August 13th, 2023

help-circle




  • The whole idea of a multitude of tactics is that some tactics work on some people and other tactics work on other people. I know of many people who wouldn’t pay attention to any criticism if they were being coddled and their oppressive behavior being tiptoed around, whereas being ridiculed and called names that accurately describe their unexamined cruelty and hypocrisy is what actually gets through to them.

    Also, maybe you deserve to be called those names and it’s the silent witnesses seeing the “debate” who are the ones whose minds are being changed. There’s a real self-centered arrogance to assume that when your hypocrisy is being called out that it’s because those calling it out are trying to change your mind as an individual, and even worse to think that you deserve to be babied and pampered into doing so.


  • LemmeAtEm@lemmy.mltoMemes@lemmy.ml•Courage
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    2 days ago

    This is a classic false equivalence fallacy.

    This is not false equivalence at all, not even a little bit. Either you are completely misunderstanding the text in the image or you don’t actually know what a false equivalence is. Or both (it’s probably both).

    You can be both anti - tankie and anti - USA.

    No shit, no one is saying otherwise. The OP image is not claiming that someone can’t be “both anti-tankie and anti-USA.” Nowhere is that implied, and it clearly is possible to be foolish enough to be both those things. That does not change the fact that when you hold “anti-tankie” positions, those positions are aligned with the US even if you consider yourself anti-USA.

    Take the issue of support for China: sure, you can be “anti-tankie” and thus erroneously believe that the CPC is an evil dictatorship while also hating the fascist US, but despising China is still aligning with the US on that position. Or for another example, take the issue of support for Ukraine: sure you can be “anti-tankie” by throwing your support behind the neo-Nazi state of Ukraine while simultaneously being “anti-USA,” but your support of Ukraine is still taking a position in alignment with the US. And that is what the OP image is referring to. There is zero false equivalence there, regardless of your stance on “tankies.”

    The other people responding to your comment are mostly focusing on pointing out the ignorance of being “anti-tankie” while also thinking you oppose the US, and they are right for doing so. But they are missing (or just glossing over) the fact that it’s your comment that is not logically sound, as it is based on a faulty premise. A little ironic that your claim of a fallacy is itself so obviously fallacious.