• 0 Posts
  • 16 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: April 28th, 2024

help-circle



  • In the current world where most of the forum discussion happen on Reddit, there is little space left for another active centralized forum.

    I strongly disagree, and there are tons of other centralized forums that are doing just fine. They’re not as big as Reddit but some have an order of magnitude (at least) more users than Lemmy does.

    The decentralized approach has at least the pro to offer something different (you can leave for another instance instead of depending on a single corporation for access).

    There are lots of ways to offer something different, and new upstarts have been able to gain traction by offering something different countless times in the past.

    Especially if we’re talking about a forum for the masses with a high number of users, the vast majority of those users simply don’t care about centralization vs federation.


  • How long do you think you’ll be needed to do that?

    I have yet to see much evidence that indicates that I won’t be needed indefinitely.

    The models are coming for your job.

    Gonna need some citations on this, chief. I don’t necessarily disagree, but proper architecture and high level analysis and design, especially of large existing systems, is something that LLMs have always been quite bad at, and I don’t think that’s going to change anytime soon. But I know the state of the art is hard to follow, so if you have any new developments to share I’d love to look at them.

    They’ll get good enough to replace you, and sooner than you think. If you think you’re safe, you’re delusional.

    I have never thought I was “safe” in this industry, going back 30 years. But I think there’s 1) a lot of questionable fear mongering going around, and 2) a very clear possibility of a talent shortage if we keep going on this trajectory.


  • Just wanted to offer a counter argument to this: I’ve been in software for a few decades and while things are changing fast, and I absolutely don’t program by hand basically ever, I still draw on my experience extensively, every day, when designing systems and reviewing code.

    My current fear is that with the drop in college CS enrollment and the lack of opportunities for junior folks to get up to speed via coding by hand, we will eventually reach a point where most of the senior folks have retired, and the remainder of the engineers won’t have the deep understanding that I and others have. This will create a shortage of experienced people who can actually solve real architectural problems and review code accurately.

    So I think there is still opportunity for someone who is motivated enough to become that “future me.” Will there be fewer of those positions available? Most likely. But I believe there will also be a huge shortage of competent candidates.


  • Also, is there any centralized forum that is more active than the Threadiverse (Lemmy/Piefed/Pylova/Mbin)?

    It looks like there are on the order of maybe 20-30k total monthly active users of the threadiverse, though I had to cobble this together from a few sources, so if you have any solid numbers I’d love to see them.

    As much drama as there is/was, the Something Awful Forums are a Web 1.0 old school centralized forum which has been around for over a quarter of a century and is still going. At their peak they had hundreds of thousands of users.

    I don’t think the argument that in order to host a large forum, you need to be decentralized holds any water. I know you’re not directly making that argument but I’ve seen others make it in their replies.



  • They have completely recovered the wiring of fruit fry brains and trained models on that architecture

    I know, and it’s an example frequently cited in these types of conversations by people who don’t understand that research.

    is a fruit fly conscious?

    Quite likely yes.

    Is a little device with all th same movement and sense capability using the fruit fly con nectome conscious

    It might be, I’m not sure. But because (quite similarly to humans) no one has a way to recreate the inputs from the outside world to pass to such a device, we don’t know.

    Though to be fair, my original claim of “it’s not possible” to recreate inputs is probably too strong — it could be possible some day, but my best understanding is that we’d need something like a time machine that allows travel to the past, at least for repeatable tests. And as far as I’m aware, most physicists today are of the opinion that time travel to the past is not possible.


  • From Wikipedia:

    The Cambridge English Dictionary defines consciousness as “the state of being awake, thinking, and knowing what is happening around you”, as well as “the state of understanding and realizing something”.

    Most of these are trivially easy to test (not sure why you think that’s impossible). And LLMs have none of those properties.

    Later:

    “The having of perceptions, thoughts, and feelings; awareness.”

    Again, LLMs have none of these things. They simply generate a probable natural-language response based on their training, deterministically.

    Feel free to do further research on your own if you’re interested.



  • How are the numbers generated by random.rand() made?

    Also, NTMs are not algorithms, they’re models of computation in theoretical computer science.

    Maybe your point is to say that a brain is performing a non computable function…but since your brain is computing that function…is that a counter example?

    This is nonsense.

    My point is that for brains, it’s not possible to recreate the exact same inputs to be able to test whether the brain produces the same output. So it’s literally not possible for brains to be deterministic.




  • I think arguments like this are misleading when discussing the question of AI possessing consciousness. Materialism, dualism, panpsychism, idealism, etc are all philosophical concepts; they attempt to answer “what is the nature of consciousness and how does it arise from the body?” from a philosophical standpoint. All of the various options have pros and cons and there is no clear “winner.”

    However, there are decent scientific definitions for consciousness. These attempt to answer the question of “what do we mean when we say something is conscious?” from a scientific standpoint. There are criteria that neuroscientists, doctors, etc generally agree on.

    So it’s not really correct to say “no one knows what consciousness is” when evaluating whether something is conscious. And I think it’s quite clear that current LLM algorithms could never be conscious, using the current accepted scientific criteria.

    (I’m not a philosopher or a neuroscientist, but I do have a degree in computer science and have a solid understanding of how LLMs work.)