

Possibly. It would depend on if they did it of their own accord, or at the government’s behest.


Possibly. It would depend on if they did it of their own accord, or at the government’s behest.


Fascist threatens to be fascist. More at 11.
Medical in particular is highly in demand. In most places in Canada if you’re coming here to work as a doctor you’ll go to the head of the queue.
OK, so let’s say you work in a company that makes cars. The workers make the cars. Their labour turns into products which the company then sells to make money. The company owner… Does nothing, basically. Management is done by managers, labour is done by labourers. Engineers designs the cars. Artists and marketeers sell them. Sure, maybe the owner is involved in a few tasks here and there, but even if they truly worked 120 hour weeks and obsessed over every little thing, their total contribution, judged as a percentage of the labour involved in making and selling those cars, would infinitesimal. Yes, they can make decisions about what new car to release, what direction to take the company, all of that, but they’re not the only person capable of making those decisions, they’re just the person who is allowed to make those decisions, because they own that privilege and no one else does.
And yet, that owner takes home billions, while the workers struggle to pay rent.
That’s the hoarding. That owner has those billions of dollars because their company sells cars. But they don’t make the cars, or even oversee the people who make the cars, they just… own it.
Now, I’m sure the counterpoint here would be that the workers have to use machines paid for by the owner. Except, the owner didn’t make those machines, they just bought them. Machines that were made with other people’s labour. If labour had access to the capital that the wealthy hoard, they could just start their own factory, sell cars that they make, and keep the profits (ie, a worker owned co-op). The wealthy owner isn’t providing, they’re gatekeeping. By controlling wealth, they control other people’s ability to deploy wealth, which in turn allows them to extract value from other people’s labour.
That’s the difference with something like Norway’s wealth fund. They’re publicly owned. The people of Norway benefit from what the wealth fund does. It’s a public good. But no one benefits from Elon Musk being rich. He didn’t even found Tesla; he paid the founders to give him the right to call himself the founder. This notion that he’s some kind of brilliant genius is a fabrication he invented about himself. He’s just a guy who had enough money to take ownership over the things that other people create. It didn’t take Elon Musk to come up with the idea of a company that makes rockets. We’ve been making rockets for thousands of years. But in a world where wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few, it requires an Elon Musk to permit people to make rockets, because he controls access to the wealth required to do so.


It’s one of those things where, like… He’s not wrong, but what a fucking awful way to phrase it.
Yes, from a coldly pragmatic perspective, funding Ukraine’s efforts to defend their sovereignty against an invading foreign power is both the morally correct choice, and an incredibly cost effective way of doing damage to a state that is directly opposed to America’s interests. Even if you don’t care that Ukrainians need American support to defend their right to life and liberty, it’s still the correct choice from a completely selfish perspective just because of how much damage is being done to Russia for very little cost.
But holy fucking yikes, ‘Beauty’ was not the word to use to explain that.
Hmm. So, I think you’re struggling to understand how those two things are connected.
First off, when we talk about “hoarding wealth”, yes, we’re including assets in that. No one here is saying that Elon has 900 billion dollars in a big old Scrooge McDuck vault. Obviously it’s all tied up in shares, bonds, real estate, etc. That makes it technically less liquid, though in practice those issues are largely irrelevant, because a) as I was pointing out in my previous reply, what the ultra-wealthy spend is such a small fraction of what they own that in practice they rarely need to dip into their less liquid assets, and b) because even larger purchases can be handled by simply taking on very cheap debt using those same assets as collateral. Basically, your credit card runs at 20%, Elon’s runs at 2%.
More to the point, that huge hoard of assets is the problem. Because their ability to buy up investments (including things that really shouldn’t be investments, like housing) makes those things more expensive for the rest of us. They can buy all the housing and rent it back to us, instead of us actually being able to afford homes.
But ultimately talking about spending habits is the answer to your question, because those raw differences in what people spend versus what they make account for huge differences in how much of our wealth we can afford to hold onto. The fact that that wealth is stored in assets rather than a bank account is completely immaterial. Or, rather, it is material, but only further proves my point.
Think about it this way; Elon can afford to have 99.9% of his wealth tied up in assets where he cannot immediately access it, and can still live a life of luxury most people couldn’t imagine in their wildest dreams. Do you think the average 9-5 worker could afford to receive even 90% of their pay in the form of assets rather than money? Or would they just be selling those assets immediately to cover their daily costs? That, right there… That’s the problem.
It’s really just simple math.
Let’s say I make $2500 a month, and I buy a car. The payments are $250 a month, so that’s 10% of my income.
If Elon Musk buys a car, even though it costs $3 million, while my car cost about $35,000, he doesn’t even need a loan. He just buys it, and the change in his bank account is so small that he can barely see the difference. He could buy ten more cars like that and not notice.
And yes, he can keep buying cars, but at some point there just stop being more cars to buy. Lamborghini can only make so many new models every year.
Maybe I spend $25 on lunch. Maybe Elon spends $2500 dollars on lunch. He spent a hundred times as much as me, but he makes millions of times more than me, and he can only eat one lunch.
So at some point there’s just a limit to how much the rich can actually spend. Yes, it’s a lot more than any single one of us, but it’s a lot less than all of us put together. We spend, they save. Where my paycheck goes into rent, car payments, food, and so on, Elon’s money goes into investments. In fact, he’s mostly paid in investments. So my money goes to other people, whereas his money stays in his pocket.
Make sense?
Well, I did, just not in the way you were looking for.
Basically, it’s more complicated than that. When we talk about wage growth, we have to start with the question “Relative to what?”
So, the actual math says that, relative to overall absolute inflation, wages have, broadly, kept up. Adjusted for inflation, median US income in 1970 was about $84,800 (just using the US as an easy example here). Today’s median income in the US is about $83,800. So, like, it’s less, but not dramatically less. Statistically, those are the same number.
But that comes with a lot of caveats. First, we’re talking about wages as a whole, but that includes, you know, CEOs. And guys making $300,000 a year to write fintech software. While the aggregate of those wages have kept up, more or less, the distribution is increasingly skewed. That’s the problem with averages; they flatten out the details.
The second caveat is the one that I already touched on, that the things we want are cheaper but the things we need are way more expensive. In 1970 the median price for a TV would be $3500 in today’s money. And that applies to things like refrigerators, stoves, all kinds of stuff. But the price of a house was only a few years of your income.
But there’s also the fact that we shouldn’t just measure against inflation. When you measure wages against productivity, that’s where you see an almost total lack of growth since the seventies. So while it is mathematically accurate to say that - in aggregate - wages have kept in line with inflation it’s also completely reasonable to question why they’re not higher. If productivity keeps going up, shouldn’t we all have more stuff now than we did then? That’s what wages and costs ultimately boil down to; the things we can have. And in a world with so much more productivity it’s crazy that having a house and two cars was easier in the 1970s than it is today.
I think the real key to understanding how inflation can be desirable is to understand that when economists talk about inflation it is with the assumption that wages will rise by an equal amount.
And, generally speaking, this is actually true. There’s a lot of nuance to that statement, so please just trust that whatever counter you have is probably contained in the nuance. But, broadly, the math checks out. We will dig into that more, later. I promise.
So, the notion is that prices go up by 2%, and then your wages go up by 2%. So how does that help anything if all we’ve done by the end of the year is reset the status quo?
Well, there are two numbers that don’t get immediately affected when your pay goes up; your savings and your debts. With slow, gentle inflation, both of these things will, over time, shrink relative to your income, while your actual buying power should, ideally, remain the same.
Say you buy a car and you agree to pay $300 a month for it. Five years later, your pay has gone up by 10%, but your car payment doesn’t go up. It’s locked at the price you agreed at the time, meaning it’s now a smaller slice of your income.
Conversely, your savings effectively shrink every year. The combined effect of this is that people with lots of savings are encouraged to spend them, while people with lots of debts are rewarded. That means more money moves though the economy, creating a healthier economy, and it means that governments, who hold lots of debt, get to shrink that debt without ever having to pay it down. The UK government still holds debts from 300 years ago, because what was a massive expenditure at the time is now just a pittance. This is why governments can run permanent deficits (within reason) and not ever have to worry about the bill coming due; because it doesn’t.
For individuals, mild inflation benefits those who buy things on credit rather than outright, which under normal circumstances means us regular shlubs who need mortgages and car loans.
If you’re trying to understand why every business now cares only about juicing their share price and not about their long term health as a company, this is a big part of why. As inflation bites, the wealthy watch as their assets decrease in comparative value, so they want those assets to grow faster than inflation. That leads to a growth at all costs mentality.
So why isn’t this working? Well, one problem is the one I just mentioned; we’ll get back to that.
But the other reason is that not all inflation is the same. When prices go up because the economy is running hot, it means that the price of everything goes up. Everything includes your labour. But when prices go up because a pandemic made shipping more expensive, or because someone started a war in Iran, that increases the input costs your company is paying for whatever it is they do, but not their profit. So your boss doesn’t suddenly have a bunch of extra money to give you a pay rise. The value of your labour hasn’t increased, but the cost of things has. So we get price inflation without wage inflation.
So this is the real disconnect; there’s good invitation and bad inflation, and they’re not the same thing (and, frankly, the fact that we don’t have different terms for them is the cause of a huge amount of confusion and misunderstanding).
Healthy inflation is the natural result of growth in an economy. Economies tend to grow, because the human population of Earth tends to grow, which means more people doing more labour, making more stuff and buying more stuff. And of course, over time we develop new technologies and practices that increase the amount of goods each human can produce, which increases what each human can sell and thus what each human can buy.
(A quick aside here; the math generally seems to agree that global population will actually stabilize at some point, probably at around 10 billion. So the human growth portion of this equation is probably only over a specific timeline, and that’s without even factoring any kind of intentional degrowth.)
The problem is that what we’ve been seeing for much of the last decade isn’t inflation, it’s price shocks, the “bad inflation” that I referred to.
If you think back past 2020, you’ll recall that the word inflation really wasn’t in the public vocabulary in the same way. It was really only something that was being talked about by weirdo libertarians, who then used the combination of price shocks and massive government spending in the pandemic to sell this notion that this why governments shouldn’t spend money. This, of course, completely ignores that governments across the world spend truly unimaginable amounts of money resolving the financial crisis just ten years earlier and inflation remained so stubbornly low that Japan had to go out of its way to try to create some.
So, in short, moderate, controlled inflation good, price shocks bad.
In theory.
But of course, there’s more to it than that, because we all agree that the quality of life we can afford today and the quality of life we could afford even as recently as the 2000s are not the same thing. The Simpsons are supposed to be a working class family barely getting by and they live in a palace by modern standards.
This is because the way we measure “inflation” doesn’t work. At least, not for our purposes. To put it really simply, if you compare what we have now against the nineties, as a portion of our income TVs and computers have gone way down, while houses and college degrees have gone way up. That’s the problem. The things we want are cheaper while the things we need are more expensive. And as income inequality worsens, this problem only gets worse, because the wealthy can afford to buy up all the assets like housing, raising their price.
The other problem is that wages increasing in line with inflation relies on labour having the power to demand increased wages, and that’s something that’s being steadily stripped away from the poorest workers. Your six figure workers can still generally demand regular pay increases, or hop jobs for a bump, but the guys pulling shifts at McDonald’s aren’t seeing those same opportunities. So while, in aggregate, wages do tend to keep up with inflation, in reality the distribution is skewed. This is where governments need to step in with things like minimum wage increases which bring the floor up for everybody (this is why, in practice, minimum wage increases have never been observed to increase inflation; they’re just correcting the side of the equation that’s currently unbalanced) and why it is absolutely vital that we protect and encourage the ability for labour to organize and collectively bargain. If we’re going to have capitalism forced down our throats, mandatory unions should be a bare minimum guardrail.
So yes, steady, moderate inflation is good… And has absolutely nothing to do with why everything is unaffordable now.


The people who voted for Trump are still there. That’s all that actually matters.
They will vote for someone like him again. It’s only a matter of when.


It doesn’t matter. How you spend the time is not important, just that you spent it. That’s what you’ll be glad of, looking back.


I never said otherwise. I’m describing behavior, you’re describing intentions. They’re just different parts of the same elephant.


The brainrot has been there for longer than his current term. What’s changed is that for the first time he’s scared of failure.
In Trump’s first term he generally acted as a helmsman to the vast ship of the party and the country, trying to steer things in his new direction. This had a limiting effect on his actions, but also an insulating effect; he was never the cause of the failure (at least in his mind).
It was generally predicted that second term Trump would no longer have any interest in working with others, listening to others, or restraining his worst instincts, and that’s exactly what we’ve seen. But with a lack of restraint comes an increase in culpability. Everything Trump touches turns to shit, and with him quite defiantly leading the charge this time round there’s no longer anyone else to blame. The tariffs, the Iran war, ICE, they’re all him.
So he’s retreating. He’s pulling back to the things that he feels confident about. In his mind, he’s a builder, a real estate guy. This is something he feels like he knows. Pools and decorations and ball rooms are his bread and butter. In his mind, at least those he can’t fuck up (he will).


Trump can’t even spell Sudetenland.


So they’re deciding who gets what, I presume?


A “sacrificial lamb” in this context is someone who agrees to be on a ballot just to put someone on the ballot. The more common term is paper candidates. Typically most don’t even campaign or anything, and certainly no money is ever spent on them. It’s the sort of thing where you just kind of sign a form and then forget about it.
It’s important for parties to establish presence everywhere you can if you want to be taken seriously, especially in a two party state, but a lot of the time “everywhere” is “The parts of Louisiana so deep red that they hunt Democrats for sport.” No one is actually planning for even the chance of a win in these places.
However, the midterms were such an ungodly bloodbath for the GOP that the Dems are winning in places they weren’t even trying to. A lot of paper candidates just woke up and learned they have new jobs.


Not arguing with that, there’s definitely a clear consent issue there. But calling out the hypocrisy is still highly effective.
Because here’s the thing; it’s the “mutilation” that gets a visceral response from voters. Most Americans are not actually going to respond all that well to discussions of consent around children’s bodies because they still fundamentally do not see children as having bodily autonomy.
This deranged fantasy story about evil Democrats transing your kids is effective because it’s about transing your kids. Only you get to do that. The child is not actually important, they’re just property that’s being vandalized.
By pointing out the obvious disconnect, Sayed takes the entire conversation to a very uncomfortable place. What was an easy rhetorical ground to occupy - mutilating children would be objectively bad - suddenly becomes much more difficult when you have to explain why some mutilation is OK. That’s exactly why the transing kids attack is normally so effective; because dems fall into the trap of either saying “It’s not happening” (people believe it is, and that’s enough for them), or saying, basically, that this mutilation is acceptable. That’s not the position we’re taking, obviously, but it sounds like the position we’re taking to them.
Shutting down the line of attack entirely is often more effective. You don’t have to play fair with people who aren’t arguing in good faith.


Oh, for sure, no argument there. I’m not defending her character, she sucks, end of discussion. I’m just pointing out that no one needs to start coming up with weird-ass conspiracy theories to explain how this happened.
Beat me to it. God those basslines are amazing, and some of the wildest drumming outside of Sleep Token.
Honestly, there’s always a tonne of great music coming out of Canada. In the same highly experimental vein you’ve got Broken Social Scene, Of Montreal and New Pornographers. For more classic rock fare there’s July Talk and Arkells, and then you’ve got Metric and Stars for a more pop-rock style. And Arcade Fire, obviously, but I’m assuming most people already know them.