• 0 Posts
  • 37 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 14th, 2023

help-circle











  • Not a reasonable analogy. Coding isn’t like making the furniture, it’s like making the assembly line that makes the furniture (or an assembly line that makes assembly lines that make furniture, etc.).

    It’s true that a factory doesn’t (and probably shouldn’t) care about deeply understanding each individual screw in each individual item. But it does (and should) care about how its assembly line is laid out — or at least the process of how that layout was determined, or the process of how that process was determined, etc.





  • No, what they said is technically accurate.

    The whole point of their architecture is that they don’t have to look up your account — but that does nothing to guarantee that they don’t decide to look up your account.

    Since you have to auth in order to generate the anonymized tokens, Kagi could (in principle) track which account generated the tokens and query that relationship when you go to use a token.

    Ultimately, if you’re not fabricating your own silicon and hand-writing your own assemblers and compilers, you gotta trust someone, so it’s good enough for my risk profile, but I can understand if that’s not good enough for some people.


  • I agree with your policy position. The three options should be:

    1. Crowd-funded, free to use, privacy preserving
    2. Paid, privacy preserving
    3. Self-hosted

    A fourth “free to use, subsidized through data collection” option shouldn’t even be legal.

    But we’re not there yet. And in order to get there, we need companies like Kagi to populate the second category so that when politicians say “but how will they make money if they can’t sell data?” we have examples to point to.


  • I too was one of those neckbeards, so I use the term with love. :)

    I certainly think we should voluntarily create some crowd-funded free-to-use services like the fediverse. But we can’t pretend that commerce doesn’t exist.

    People are going to try to make money by hosting stuff online and enticing people to go there and use it. I would prefer if those people made money by charging admission instead of by collecting and selling data.


  • Huh? How exactly do you package privacy? It’s something you can lose, but not something you can buy.

    Kagi is selling search, same as Google. The difference is that you can only pay in dollars, not data.

    I agree it’s overpriced, but this is where we are. The actual market for genuine web services is atrophied after 30 years of neckbeards naively insisting that web services should be free. Search should cost $5/year by now. But oh well, 30 years too late is better than never.