Useless frothing liberal drivel
2-3 years into a genocide and then 2-3 weeks into another war full of war crimes by the west but the liberal still wants to hold onto international legalism as if it some magic paper.
Only people who have the privilege of buying into the above paradigm are willing to be so easily outraged as they preach imperialist talking points from the “left”:
Useless frothing liberal drivel
A bit harsh. I can understand where he is coming from, emotionally, even if rationally i think his outrage is misplaced. Or maybe i’m just inclined to be a little more forgiving with Ali Abunimah because i really appreciate the work he does with Electronic Intifada.
Electronic Intifada
https://electronicintifada.net/content/china-imports-israels-methods-propaganda-and-repression/9160
If we understand that criticism against Chomsky is more than “he only pointed out just some of the symptoms of imperialism” but he was actually an enthusiastic agent for empire by denigrating those who understood the science of capital, imperialism and how to defeat them then we should understand the problem with these left-liberals. It is the left liberalism that prevents scientific socialism from spreading faster - the anti-cancer Reiki practitioner who prevents chemotherapy only helps to accelerate the growth of malignancy.
I’m not mad, just disappointed…😞
I’m not mad, just disappointed
I totally sympathise with this feeling.
(I edited my previous comment to add an explanation for those links.)
We live in a liberal world and have to consume liberal media to be able to decipher the world because we are starved of more scientific resources. This is just part of the science of how to navigate this hegemony; we have to be detectives on top of everything else and ngl it is can be fucking exhausting.
we have to be detectives on top of everything else and ngl it is can be fucking exhausting.
100
China (and Russia too to an extent) is careful not to alienate anyone in the region, because they want to work with and rally everyone. In West Asia, they work within a situation inherited from US and UK imperialism - none of this was of their own making, and the culprits are still around to focus on.
Iran and Yemen are letting Chinese and Russian ships through their straits, there’s a lot we just don’t see happening beneath the surface. In 2024, Hamas and the PA met for talks in Russia and China. but that’s the thing with living in the time of an imperial hegemon, we learn to only respond to the big showy explosions.
Iran seems to approve of Russia and China’s actions. I will trust their judgement
Both Russia and China have said pretty clearly that they condemn the unjustified aggression against Iran and support its right to defend itself. We also know that they are both almost certainly providing material and intelligence support.
Resolutions like this are more performative than anything else, and their reluctance to use their veto is easily explained by the fact that Russia and China also have and want to maintain good relations with the Gulf Arab states.
And would it have changed anything at all, substantively, if they vetoed it? I don’t like it either but that was probably their reasoning. It doesn’t mean they support the resolution.
I also think sometimes people tend to overstate the importance of these resolutions.
And i think we’ve had the discussion before about how, at least in China’s case, they have a record of using their veto power extremely sparingly due to how they see the veto as drawing them into a larger commitment which they seldom want to make.
Both Russia and China have said pretty clearly that they condemn the unjustified aggression against Iran and support its right to defend itself.
Really? When?
https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/opinions/2026/3/19/chinas-silence-on-iran-reveals-its-true-priorities
With Russia preoccupied with its own war, Iran waited to see whether its only other ally capable of going toe to toe with the US, China, would come to its aid. The answer came quickly. Two days into the war, during a regular news conference at the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, business continued as normal, as if the US and Israel had not just attacked one of China’s comprehensive strategic partners. When it became clear that China would remain silent, an Iranian journalist protested. Only then did the ministry spokesperson, Mao Ning, reluctantly condemn the US-Israeli assault.
In the days that followed, China became a vocal critic of the attacks. Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi argued, “Might does not make right,” warning that the attacks proved that “the world has regressed to the law of the jungle.” Yet for all his strong words, Wang stopped short of explicitly naming the US or Israel as the aggressor, even if there was little doubt which countries he meant. Furthermore, China offered Iran little substantive assistance beyond rhetoric.
While China contacted several Middle Eastern countries and sent a special envoy on a diplomatic tour of the region, a move that helped prevent Iran’s neighbours, many caught in the crossfire, from joining the fray, it made no attempt to directly confront the US, the country ultimately responsible for the war, let alone send Iran military aid.
China’s response remained muted even when Iran, in a bid to provoke international intervention, closed the Strait of Hormuz, a vital maritime corridor through which 40 percent of China’s imported oil passes each day. Faced with a direct threat to its economic lifeline, Beijing’s only response was to call for all parties to cease hostilities and return to the negotiating table. Its priorities were clear.
China immediately condemned the attack on Iran:
https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202603/01/WS69a42333a310d6866eb3af12.html
They have since called for peace and de-escalation but never once condemned Iran for defending itself.
Russia of course condemned the attack on Iran. They also explicitly stated that they support Iran’s right to self-defense:
https://tass.com/politics/2100609?ysclid=mmzgz1rpsg854907143
Considering that AJ is Qatari state media i don’t think they are exactly an unbiased source on this.
You think Qatari state media would be disavowing China for not supporting Iran enough?
Yes. Al-Jazeera has a history of trying to stir up anti-China sentiment. You would know this if you followed their reporting on China for a few years. They are also not exactly pro-Iran and have a vested interest in driving a wedge between the two.
Vetoing would polarize Saudi towards the US.
China just signed an oil deal with Saudi in Yuan a couple years back. It’s what mitigated the financial damage that this war has caused.
Now that the terms of engagement has expanded to targeting oil infrastructure, it would render this mitigation null and void.
Not to mention that in case of Japanese / US aggression in east Asia, China still needs to rely on Saudi Oil. (Kind of) Because the US is able to provide oil to its vassals in the region to fuel the invasion.
People should look at how Iran speaks about Russia and China, not make up their own litmus tests for China and Russia to pass out of thin air.
It’s such an energy drain and self-own to be making up arbitrary stuff these countries have to do to “prove themselves” while ignoring the relationships they have in the geopolitical world.
I’ve got nothing against this guy in particular, mind. It’s more I’m getting really tired of this kind of thing in general. People have got to stop believing that the western-led circus performance is the substance. Look at where material connections of support and solidarity lie. Political power comes “from the barrel of a gun” (and related: control over the means of production and distribution). Legislative abstraction atop that is only as legitimate as the guns behind it and whose interests they serve. The UN is not, and has never been, a neutral organization in the hands of a fair and balanced world order; the unipolar western military power and its interests is fundamentally opposed to such a goal.
People have got to stop believing that the western-led circus performance is the substance.
THANK YOU!





