I’m a software engineering developer from Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.

  • 0 Posts
  • 5 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 6th, 2023

help-circle

  • The issue here is treating Israelis as a monolith. Yes the religious nutbags (or Haredi if you want to be technical) maintain that Mizrathi aren’t arab. So do many of the conservative older people. Many of the younger more urban Israelis are much more open minded. I have some Mizrathi family where the parents refuse to admit that they are Arabs (despite the fact that if they put on traditional Arabic clothes they’d look like the complete Arab stereotype), but their kids are proud to be Arab Jews. As is often the case, its the next generation where hope lives. The crotchety old folks are unlikely to change their minds.


  • I know of at least 10 Arabic Jews that voted Ra’am. I also know of at least 50 or so Muslim Arab Israelis that definitely do not identify as Palestinian. In the urban centres deeper in Israel (around Tel Aviv) its a bit more common. I also know some Ashkenazi Jews who identify as Palestinian, though most of them were forced to leave (despite one family having lived near Ramallah since at least the 1850s).

    As for the Druze I tend to agree with your sentiment… Its still that way for Jews in many countries too unfortunately. Personally I dont think religion should play any part in politics (up to religions effecting other people). Too bad it so often does.


  • Yeah, that’s mostly what the population was before the formation of the modern state. Now there are a few other key groups. One massive one is the ~40% of the Israeli population that are Jewish Arabs (who Israel classifies as non-Arab, despite being clearly an Arabic people [many speak Arabic as native language, and most are from MENA]). Another group are the sizeable group of Arab Muslims that identify as Israeli rather than Palestinian. Then of course there are the Christian/Druze/Bedouin groups that identify with the varying states to varying degrees. The thing that makes it tough as that both states (whether legitimate or not, I think its fair to say that both Israel and Palestine are de facto states) refuse to release demographics for people who would identify as a certain ethnicity and a certain nationality (Israel treats all Jews as a single ethnic block, Palestine doesn’t count [most] Jews as citizens, both groups are sizeable). Part of the confusion does come from the fact that the Palestinian government (in the West Bank, not Hamas, they’re stricter) claims that any non-Jew living in Israel is actually a Palestinian; but that simply is not the case (any more than every Han person in Taiwan being part of the PRC).

    In the recent election, Ra’am got a lot of votes from Arabic Jews who would certainly disagree with the idea of being Palestinian. The Joint List has a more Palestinian core voter base, but still attracts support from non-Palestinian groups. Netanyahu would love if everyone would spread the idea that both groups are Palestinians and thus don’t have “skin in the game” when it comes to Israeli politics. Thus his constant rhetoric these days that they are.


  • I’d be careful referring to the Arab parties as Palestinian. You’re assumption is correct, but backwards. Bibi uses that term to disenfranchise them, saying “they don’t believe in Israel, so they shouldn’t count”. Most of the Arab parties get a lot of support from non-Palestinian Arab Israelis. Eroding that identity is a great way to silence their votes, especially at a time when they could make the difference between continued genocide and progress towards coexistence. Netanhayu would like nothing more than to convince the world that the Arab parties are “just Palestinian”. Of note is that Ra’am doesn’t even support the dissolution of the state of Israel, but instead formalization of a two-state solution.