A Tennessee court has overturned the conviction of a man who killed a Black transgender woman, ruling that a lower court “erred” by preventing the killer from using the victim’s trans identity in his defense.
Samuel Ward Jr. shot Paris Lee six times outside her Memphis home in June 2022, according to the Shelby County District Attorney’s Office. He then drove 30 minutes home, leaving her to die. Ward was convicted of voluntary manslaughter in May 2025.
But the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals in Jackson overturned that conviction on Monday and ordered a retrial. The trial court’s judge had disallowed the defense from presenting the victim’s identity as a transgender woman in its arguments.
“The trial court erred by excluding evidence of the victim’s assigned sex at birth, [and] the evidence was insufficient to support [Ward’s] conviction,” reads the Monday appellate court decision. “Because we conclude that the trial court erred… we reverse and remand this case for a new trial.”
The defense had argued it would be more reasonable for Ward to fear Lee if jurors knew she was assigned male at birth, and said jurors would be more prejudiced against Ward for killing a cisgender woman, according to Jamie Satterfield, an independent journalist who first reported the ruling.
The gay panic defenses has not gone away. Also, this rings of saying its not murder because transgender people aren’t people.
Wait, wtf? What does that have to do with anything?
if I’m being extremely generous their (still very fucked up) argument is that a jury would be more likely to believe there was an imminent threat of harm from a “biological male” than a “biological female”. They might even be correct with regards to how the information would impact the views of a Tennessee jury.
Still completely fucked and demonstrates a huge part of what’s wrong with our judicial system. Everything a jury needs to know about whether a person would reasonably feel in imminent danger can be described without ever mentioning sex or gender.
threat of harm from a “biological male” than a “biological female”.
Seems to me basing that on gender is sexism. Absolutely statistically this is true, but the case was presumably based on the individuals in question, not on statistics. The evidence should determine the case not prejudice.
The trial court’s judge had disallowed the defense from presenting the victim’s identity as a transgender woman in its arguments.
That’s a good call to avoid prejudice.
Gay panic, now trans flavored!
Always has been
Now comes in Blue, White, and Pink!
Did he kill someone? Then it doesn’t fucking matter what the victim’s gender or plumbing was.
Yes it does. Because this case may be used as precedence in other cases matter on. If something was not done correctly, this isn’t justice, it’s corruption. And it could lead to things like not allowing trans representation in legal proceedings(unlikely, but so was a convicted felon, and paedophile becoming USA’s president)

black people, immigrants, and indigenous people too. atp, to stop the constant social murder and actual murder, we’ve got to force it on people. I don’t want to become radicalized and lose my life or some shit fighting against the state, but if they’re just letting people get lynched again, then I have to.
A hate crime, then…?
In California maybe - but Tennessee? This feels like fuckery to me.
It’s Tennessee, of course it’s fuckery. They have one of the worst state governments in the country.
trans rights are human rights
You have been banned from c/Conservatives.
Ha ha ha. You too? They are aggressive about banning anyone that challenges their manipulation of their sheep.








