Ginny [they/she]

  • 0 Posts
  • 43 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 16th, 2023

help-circle










  • Dude, just stop with the colonial apologia.

    Not a dude, and not doing apologetics or trying to justify anything, either. I am merely making the point that if the British are to be judged on the sins of our fathers to the third and fourth generation, then I don’t think merely no longer being a part of the same continuing political entity absolves the Irish of theirs. But quite frankly I don’t give a shit who was to blame for what, because I’m not actually in any way culpable for anything anyone did before I was born.

    People don’t really hate the English other than when they begin to justify their colonial atrocities.

    Then why are we talking about colonialism? I never mentioned colonialism. I made a joke in the meme community about how I (an English person, FWIW) hate the English because I hate currently living in England. (Try and guess why.) It was Tomorrow Farewell who came in apparently putting the argument that Scotland and Wales deserve to be hated just as much due to the crimes of the past, and I just felt like pointing out that even on those terms both Irish people and Scottish people have been both victims and perpetrators to varying degrees.

    The oppressed are coerced into the military all the time. The shtick is to make their living conditions so horrible, their chances of employment so shit that they have no other choice other than to join the military that provides them with the only reprieve.

    Do you think every Irish person who served in the British army had no choice in the matter, but the English and Scottish soldiers were doing it only for the love of the game?

    Scotland willing got into the union.

    The Scottish nobility wanted into the union, and even then only after the failure of the Darien plan. That wasn’t true for the Scottish as a whole, and certainly not true of the Highlanders who were forcibly displaced and had their culture and language suppressed in many of the same ways the Irish did, contemporaneously.


  • Have you missed the last several hundred years or so, featuring British colonialism and genocides conducted with the involvement of the British?

    The colonialism we did with a navy that was about 20% Irish and an army that was about 30% Irish? Ireland hardly innocent on that front.

    Oh? What was their analogue of the Irish Potato Famine?

    Admittedly, it’s quite hard to do a potato famine to someone. It’s more a thing you take advantage of when it happens. But the Highland Clearances and the Highland Potato Famine were happening at roughly the same time.


  • Unwilling collaborators to what, exactly?

    To the troubles? The Partition of Ireland? The Tudor Conquest of Ireland and the Plantation of Ulster? The British Empire in general? Or whatever the fuck the Britain is doing on the world stage now?

    There isn’t much of anything that Britain has done to Ireland that England didn’t also do to Scotland, or the Anglo-Normans to Wales.

    But I was just going by the fact that England is where all the Tory voters are.




  • Only in the US.

    Not really. We don’t use the word liberal in the UK anywhere near so much, but any average person (as opposed to a person well into polsci) describing themselves as “liberal” would be understood to be saying that they are progressive on social issues, not that they are in favour of free markets (though that may or may not be the case).

    The “Liberal Democrats” in the UK are not understood to be the opposite of the Tories

    Eh, yes and no. It is historically correct that the Liberal in Liberal Democrats refers to capital L Liberalism, being a merger of the Liberal Party and the Social Democratic Party, but the fact that the Lib Dems and the Tories are basically aligned on economic policy and only differ on how much they hate multiculturalism and trans people only serves to give the impression to people not well read in theory that that is what makes them “liberal”, if anything.

    The reason liberal is understood to mean the opposite of conservative in the US is only because historically socialism became such a dirty word, liberals did everything they could to distance themselves from it, and there was no major socialist party or movement.

    Perhaps. I’m not actually from the US.

    Since socialism has become resurgent, it makes more sense, especially on an international platform like this one, to adopt the internationally understood meaning.

    No, it doesn’t, because there isn’t one single internationally understood meaning. That is why the word has multiple definitions in the dictionary; some of them relate to liberalism as a political ideology, and some of them don’t. You aren’t going to succeed in building community or solidarity with anyone if the first thing you do is tell them that they’ll aren’t using their words correctly because they aren’t using it according to your list of acceptable definitions.