I don’t have very much experience on cordless tools apart from using DeWalt at home and Makita at work, both at a DIY level capacity. The 18V era is as capable as I will ever need. While trying to expand the range of tools at home though, the influx of house brands (Worksite at my local store) at very low prices became enticing. These items often advertise battery compatibility with big brands and seem sturdy enough. Wonder what everybody is using and how did you make the decision?

I have been impressed with Hercules from Harbor Freight as a DIYer. I use their 20V tools.
Yeah, HF really stepped up their game over the years. I can’t speak about cordless, but recently I bought three corded tools and am impressed. Really solid and powerful. ‘Will need to replace my beloved DeWalt cordless driver soon and will seriously consider HF offerings.
I’m a carpenter. I use Dewalt, because the first tool I got after moving out of my parent’s house, was a dewalt drill, and I don’t want a bunch of different batteries laying around.
Truth is, it doesn’t matter which brand you use. In the end it’s mostly religion. If you don’t plan on building a house, most discount tools will work just fine for those 2 times per year you need to drill a hole, og saw a plank with a circular saw. If you’re only going to use an impact drill a few times per year, the cheap one for $20 is likely going to last you a lifetime. Don’t get caught up in branding, it’s all mostly the same, unless you’re a professional who uses the tools every single minute of every single day.
If you’re going to use it that infrequently, you’d have to make a good case for getting a battery-powered tool–there’s two more things that can go wrong or get lost.
I’ll try to answer your question. Get the cheap stuff. Once it breaks, buy the name brand.
If you don’t already have dewalt/milwaukee/makita then buy the brand that’s easiest for you to get.
For example i started with makita then moved and my local store only carries Milwaukee.
I’ve used off brand makita compatible products and they’ve worked well enough. Don’t get off brand batteries though.
If I had to start over I would be buying harbor freight brand.
I use Dewalt 20v, I have built antenna’s with them. Fine product. Milwaukee would be #2.
Going cheap\economical I would go Harbor Freights line.
Torque Test Channel on youtube if you want some data. They have teated some cheaper brands as well.
We have 2 ranges.
Milwaukee for work. - started the range many years ago and really once you have a few items it’s easier to stick with them. Main items are all 10 years old now and still have some life left. Friend has all dewalt and they seem pretty solid too.
Ryobi for around the house/garden. It’s enough for small to medium-high task. Cheaper price point and decent garden/cleaning selection. I did have a problem with one garden tool, after a year, Ryobi were very accommodating in sorting it. I also use a few third party batteries with these product, which takes price point down quite a bit.
I did pick up a Hyundai cordless lawnmower, last year. Reason bigger battery and self propelled at a cheaper price to Ryobi. They messed up the sale sent a lesser product and blamed me, had to threaten with court action to get the product I paid for. Looked to be a beast on paper but has had a few faults, and is fussy with some grass types. Given Hyundais past cust service I’ll take it as a loss.
What third party batteries do you use for your Ryobi tools? I’m looking to add a spare but want to make sure a 3rd party brand is trustworthy.
I bought mine via eBay. I have had a few over the years, I’m sure there are internet recommendations of providers but I just popped on eBay and checked reviews. Usually a different seller each time.
I have a few sizes from the 2.5 to the 5H. The 5 has a lot more juice but is an uneven weight at one end for my hedge trimmer. I favour the 3.5/4 in general. The only tool that’s fussy is the small chainsaw. It only likes a 2.5.
Mine look like the pic below but it’s irrelevant really, I suppose reviews will be the best guide. I see no difference in performance against the genuine batteries. Infact I only have one genuine left now the 2.5. I’ve had no weird noises, no power drops…some are nearing 5/6 yr old, all the light indicators still work etc. I have about 6, I did have a few more but gave them away with the lawnmower.

Agree on 18 volt being a solid foundation. 20 volt packs are just 18 volt packs with some additional marketing.
I was on team orange back in 2010 in the early lithium days. Their batteries had no balancing at that time, which made me jump to team blue when the batteries became useless a year in. I’ve been on team blue ever since but…
I bought some team green 40 volt yard tools back in 2016 and have been hooked. Their string trimmer, edger, and poll trimmer have served me well. Although I have a team blue corded chainsaw, I bought a team green battery unit too.
If I was starting over I would probably just choose the brand that offers products in the segment(s) you care about. I’ve accumulated an 18 volt 1/4 impact, 1/2 drill, circular saw, sawzall, and angle grinder. The last three were pretty unique on the cordless market when I bought them and they’ve been very useful. Most of the mainstream brands will be more than performant enough for diy stuff.
tl;dr I’m changing teams and needed to vent about it a bit.
I currently use Team Green for smaller powered hand tools, but my most recent purchase with them has unfortunately soured the relationship. Of the 3 tools in the combo, two of them lived absurdly short lives. The drill had some clutch issue that it fail when in high speed (it would not engage, allowing for a drill bit to be stationary while the drill made a lot very promising sounds), and the oscillating tool became a very lackluster flashlight after a few months, though it was very lightly used. The first wood blade (the only one I used) is in good condition. I’ve had one of their higher end impact drivers for quite awhile and it has been everything I’ve wanted it to be. Oh, and their sawzall is such poor quality that the blunt end of the blade managed to both knock off the guard, and when I continued using it because “shrug, guards pop off from the vibration all the time, I didn’t consider any further possibilities on why the guard would remove itself” friction cut its way through the housing and rather thin metal protective layer.
But since that particular purchase was so tragically awful, I’m considering changing teams. Red team is something I’d consider, but they are incredibly expensive to get started in. Yellow is alright, but I use them professionally and would rather not conflate ownership if ever the need pops up.
I think I may end up on team cyan, I just haven’t really looked into them in a long while and have no idea where they stand anymore, or the general accessibility of the brand.
Worst part about the ryobi sawzall was the tasks it has started to fail itself on. I was cutting through the less than one by sections of a few pallets. They were not in great shape and the diablo blade made short work of them. It seems like a rather large design flaw.
That stinks to hear. Team orange and team green are actually on the same team. On the 40v side of things, team green is the only house brand on offer, so they’re a pretty solid product. Both team green and team orange are available on the 18v side of things, with team green positioned as a lower tier.
Maybe this is something to put in the back of all our heads: there are multiple leagues each team competes in. Just because the same team is in a second lead does not mean that it will do well in that league.
Team orange? Rigid? Black and decker?
Rigid.
Ryobi is garbage, but DeWalt, Makita, and Milwaukee should treat you well… pick your color and stick to it.
I’m using some makita stuff for around the house because I got a good deal on it. I’m using some craftsman stuff in the yard because I have accumulated batteries for those tools. I think once you start collecting the batteries, you might as well stick with the ecosystem. “Prestige” brands will just cost you more for doing the same basic projects.
I just have HyperTough tools for every day home shit. They’re cheap, but durable and work as adverised. They are also 20 volt.





