Bonta claimed OpenAI created a public nuisance and violated the state’s unfair competition laws.
What? They committed a crime, right? Hacking someone else’s computer is something you normally go to prison for. It’s a crime and needs to be treated as such, or you’ll create a situation where AI systems are somehow above the law. They’re property, and the owner is fully responsible for it. OpenAI is the owner.
That would be a federal offense probably as it was over state lines. The state is going to bring the charges it thinks it has standing to. Granted the feds should bring charges but we know they won’t.
Yeah maybe next time they’ll unplug the ethernet cable from the totally offline system.
Good. AI companies need to be held liable for things their products do without being told to.
Good. AI companies need to be held liable for things their products do
without being told to.I’d bet money that the AI was told to do it.
It doesn’t even matter whether the AI was told to do it. It’s their tool, they made it, they own it, they control it. They’re fully responsible for everything it does. Nobody else told it to do this, therefore they, directly or indirectly, made it do this. They intentionally made a tool capable of doing this. Whatever it does is on them. Completely.
OpenAI commited a crime. Simple as that.
It absolutely matters. It’s the difference between criminal negligence and an intentional action.
Regardless of whether or not it was told to do something, it means the product does not have sufficient safeguards in place. They should absolutely be held liable.
It absolutely was. They told it to get information via exploits, and that’s what it did. They either knew this would happen or were so shockingly incompetent that the people involved should have been fired immediately. But I suspect the former as it’s been used as a PR stunt.
They want there to be a public perception that their AI tools are far and away above the capabilities of humanity (and thus more valuable to shareholders), while also sufficiently dangerous in the ‘wrong hands’ to convince the U.S. government to prevent China from stockpiling GPUs and creating open-weight AI competition to their corporate cabal.
Yeah it was probably told to do it, and iirc the test environment was not properly secured. So it tried stuff and realized internet access worked.
Yeah, it’s bs when they say AI “escaped” its sandbox. No, it walked out because you didn’t have the proper guardrails.
I mean, they were intentionally testing what the model could do without guardrails. The problem is that the sandbox isolation was not sufficient.

I had a coworker argue that it was impossible to sandbox the AI, like it was going to get out no matter what they did.

You know, if I think of Fox News as The Onion it’s suddenly a lot better.
Fuck that ogre
OpenAI spokesperson Drew Pusateri told the BBC in a statement that Bonta’s lawsuit “appears to single out OpenAI over a challenge that’s been identified by every major AI lab”.
You can fuck off, Drew. The problem isn’t “AI misalignment,” the problem is you making systems you don’t understand well enough to contain, and saying “that’s just the price of doing business”. If a fireworks factory exploded in the middle of downtown LA because they let their employees smoke outside the back door, that doesn’t make the company less liable for the dead civilians.
Why sue? Why not not prosecute?
A criminal case has an incredibly high standard to prove guilt, is lead by the government, and seeks to punish offenders. It’s more difficult and Hugging Face has nothing to gain.
A civil case has a lower standard, is lead by the plaintiff’s legal team, and seeks to reimburse the plaintiff for damages. Civil cases are often settled out of court for a portion of the possible damages without even needing to argue. It’s an easy cash payout for Hugging Face.
Hugging Face may have nothing to gain, but that has never stopped prosecutors from prosecuting people who hacked into other people’s computers. Why make an exception just because this time it was a valuable company?
Because it’s a civil violation, not a criminal one.
Hacking isn’t a criminal violation?
I’m not sure if California state law has it as a crime on their books. The CFAA is a federal law.





